Skip to main content

Table 1 Barriers to recruitment, retention and intervention delivery

From: Barriers to recruitment, retention and intervention delivery in a randomized trial among patients with firearm injuries

Challenge

Description

Resolution

Recruitment

 Maximizing patient enrollment

• Unpredictable patient arrival times

• Limited funding for full-time staff coverage

• Use of online resources for patient tracking

• Flexible staff schedules

• Prompt enrollment of discharged patients

 Optimizing patient approach

• Working with medical care providers

• Visiting friends and family

• Imminent discharge

• Consultation with physicians on research staff

• Consultation with medical care providers in hospital

• Maintain rapport with medical care providers and visitors

• Frequent check-ins

• Leave brochure for patient to review

Retention

 Retaining unresponsive participants

• Housing instability

• Frequently changing phone numbers

• Limited cellular service or internet access

• Poor communication affecting intervention delivery

• Frequent communication attempts

• Try all available methods and contacts

• Attempt to meet patients at scheduled medical visits

• Support Specialist independently attempt contact

• Provide incentives to help with phone service/transportation

• Offer visits in the community

 Retaining participants with limited time

• Good communication but low availability

• Working hours conflict with research staffing times

• Poor availability affecting intervention delivery

• Data collection via in-person, phone and online

• Use text messages, email, and social media for contact

• Contact outside of work hours (e.g., evenings and weekends)

• Meet at scheduled medical appointments

• Combine follow-up and intervention appointments

Intervention Delivery

 Connecting participants with community resources

• No limits on the areas of concern for recovery

• Some needed resources unavailable (e.g., housing)

• Use well-trained staff with social work background

• Community-based advisory team to help identify resources

• Build rapport by focusing first on available resources

• Rapport building helps with problem solving to identify other needed resources

 Communication between research staff and Support Specialist

• First contact with the Support Specialist ideally in-person and in-hospital.

• Options needed for patients discharging quickly

• Some patients may not want face-to-face contact due to nature of injuries

• Research staff able to accurately describe intervention

• Notify Support Specialist well in advance of initial approach

• Flexible scheduling

• Use phone-based delivery of the initial contact, if needed

• Short intro video to familiarize patient with Support Specialist, if needed